Interesting discussion here @ottodv@Steel.Key. Feel like this is a very broad topic that is tough to advance on but let’s try and move forward.
Without taking either side, just a suggestion - let’s split the topic at hand into 2 portions:
discussing the merits of locking SWISE in exchange for some benefits
protocol fee distribution. and revisit the earlier discussion about locking SWISE
For (1) someone could compile a summary of the key arguments on each side from this thread and the earlier thread on SWISE locking:
For (2) we could revisit the thread we had before & collect arguments from this thread for a summary as well:
Then the community could discuss the summary and vote. I suggest we start with the locking topic because it seems to invite the most contention and matters the most for the protocol in terms of $ value at play.